Israel's daily newsmagazine
   Israel's daily newsmagazine
| home |   security |   politics |   diplomacy |   anti-semitism |   culture |   travel |   views | today's weblog  
 
Anti-expulsion Protests

   



 
Sign up for free!

E-mail
 
         
    Subscribe    
         










Ellen W. Horowitz lives in the Golan Heights with her husband and six children. She is a painter, writer and political activist.
ellen@artfromzion.com
Previous views
Mr. Ed Was Not German-Bred
Play it again, Uncle Sam
The stolen Scream and the difference between disasters
Shabbat preparations under siege
Shabbat preparations under siege
Getting it right: birthpangs of a new Israel
When the Right is Wrong
The Jewish State--Vessel or Vassal?
John, George, or Judah?
No to civil war among Jews
Refocus and remember
Seeing Red in Stockholm
Lines of deception
The dark at the end of the tunnel
Where are the men?
A case for Netanyahu
Beyond the right of self-defense

Bodyguards defend Defense Minister from irate Jewish protesters in Gaza
Anti-expulsion forces chain shut hundreds of Tel Aviv area schools
Anti-expulsion protesters surprise police again, blocking Tel Aviv freeway
Security minister says MK Eitam called for collecting weapons of expellees
Agent Provocateur Exposed, Gag Order Imposed
IDF Colonel fears settlers' fury
Settlement supporters: mass action will prevent expulsion
Views: Refusing to Obey Orders
Baaah, humbug! Judge shears size of "sheep protest"

 
Is it all for naught?
By Ellen W. Horowitz   April 27, 2005


According to our sages, after hearing Pharaoh's decree that all male newborns be thrown into the Nile, Amram -- the leader of the Israelite community -- divorced his wife in order to set an example and prevent suffering and infanticide. Other commentaries suggest that Amram separated from Yocheved in a state of utter despair, declaring, "It is all for naught!" At the time, Amram was unaware that he had already planted the seed of redemption (Yocheved was three months pregnant with Moshe).

For a Jew, perhaps nothing is more agonizing than feeling as if one's efforts have been wasted; and yet, it is often our greatest moments of anguish and despair that allow for the possibility of deliverance.

According to some midrashim, Amram's voluntary and exemplary act of separation from his wife is seen as a great action in G-d's eyes (see Aviva Zornberg's Reflections on Exodus). This is strange and seems to run contrary to family-oriented Jewish tradition. Many of us are familiar with, and more comfortable with, the commentaries that give credit to Miriam's greatness in admonishing her father and reconciling her parents (and consequently the rest of the Israelite couples).

But it seems that Amram's greatness lies in his authenticity and righteousness, as authentic cries, groans and pain can be heard and felt in the heavenly realms. Our remarkable ability to turn inward in times of severe crisis -- in search of our true selves -- while simultaneously reaching outward to G-d is quite possibly the greatest of all human achievements. It's no easy task, and yet it doesn't require any of the qualities we mortals usually attribute to exceptional accomplishment. In fact, great intellect, talent, and self-confidence are actually a hindrance to effective introspection; whereas, a shattered ego can release an imprisoned soul. This is when true prayer becomes possible. And, ironically, it's this occasional exchange of our external selves and physical labors with an intense and existential grappling and questioning of the purpose and direction of our efforts that can activate a redemptive response from On High. This type of exertion can transcend logic and appears to be almost other-worldly, and that may be why it seems to elicit an appreciative response from the heavenly realms.

We entered the month of Nissan having expended tremendous energy towards trying to avert Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's decrees concerning the Gaza Strip. Our benign efforts and use of acceptable and lawful channels seemed spent. And, in the best of Jewish tradition, we did take a moment to separate from the mundane in order to pause and reflect. I think I speak for many of us when I say that garnering the resources and stamina necessary to focus on Pesach preparations was particularly tedious and draining this year. And perhaps a few of us were asking, "Is it all for naught?"

And then, perhaps miraculously, we got word of a three-week delay in Sharon's Disengagement Plan. Maybe the "bulldozer" is having engine problems, second thoughts, or tactical difficulties. Whatever the reason, we got a welcome reprieve just in time for the holiday. And it seems that a lot of us are enjoying an exceptionally joyful Pesach. Although we rarely see immediate results, I'm quite sure that our sincere efforts and expressions on all fronts and in all realms throughout the years have been well worth it.

Take a moment to look back and see what we've done and how we've struggled to stop the unstoppable and "irreversible" process The current battle to secure and preserve the Jewish communities in Gaza and the Shomron is part of the continuing war against everything Oslo wrought. I believe that our determination, efforts, and exceptional stamina and spirit have made an impact. One day, we may merit seeing the miraculous fruits of our labors.

Views expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect those of israelinsider.


 Talk Back! Respond to this view



Click on the blue headline to read a Talkback comment and respond to it. Click on the icon to send a private email to the talkback writer. The icon appears only if the writer has decided to be contacted. If no popup window appears, please make sure your popup blocker allows israelinsider.com.

 
  | about |   partners |   sponsor |   donate |   news |   subscribe |   contact |