Israel's daily newsmagazine
   Israel's daily newsmagazine
| home |   security |   politics |   diplomacy |   anti-semitism |   culture |   travel |   views | today's weblog  
 
Politics > "Disengagement" Plan

   



 
Sign up for free!

E-mail
 
         
    Subscribe    
         










Naomi Ragen is the Jerusalem-based author of Chains Around the Grass. Information on her books and mailing list can be found on her website at NaomiRagen.com.
Previous views
Rushing into the abyss
A season of hope
Who is the enemy?
Am I Right-wing or Left-wing?
Jerusalem night out
The mall model for MidEast peace
Another parallel universe
Getting up to dance, again
What about a goodwill gesture from the Palestinians?
To the families of the Passover massacre victims
The Passover massacre: one year later
A little advice on war and peace from an Israeli
The people I live amongst
Jane, Yasser, Shoshana and Mitzna
I don't understand
To live with terror

Second refusenik soldier gets prison sentence
The color... orange?
IDF soldier wounded in Nablus
Security forces raid "Hotel Disengagement"
IDF reopens Gaza Strip
Pullout opponents attempt to block entrance to Jerusalem again
Views: Thank G-d for Ariel Sharon
Settlers clash with Palestinians, IDF at "outpost" in Shirat Hayam
Likud rebels conduct poll, shows 48% Israelis for pullout, 41% opposed

 
You've won, Mr. Sharon. I'm disengaged.
By Naomi Ragen   July 3, 2005


I'm watching the news on television. The screen is filled with a major Israeli security operation. Seven hundred police are involved, with major military backup.

Could it be, perhaps, an attack on Hizbullah, which just sent three terrorists to infiltrate Israel, and attacked Har Dov with artillery fire, killing a 20-year-old soldier from Beersheva?

No. They are involved in clearing out a bunch of teenagers from an abandoned hotel in Gush Katif!

There are ten soldiers and policemen for every kid. I see them dragging the children by their legs. I see them putting a young girl in a head hold. It takes them twenty minutes, tops, to empty the "right-wing extremist stronghold."

And this is how I feel: Disengaged, in the real sense of the word, not Mr. Sharon's spin. I feel detached, withdrawn, my ties and obligations severed.

Who are these people who are running my country? I didn't elect them. I voted for those who promised to support Gush Katif, to fight terrorism. I sent my son to the army to shoulder arms and risk his young life to protect his people, not drag them kicking and screaming out of their homes. Not to mount a little war against a bunch of miserable teenagers.

Of course, you'd never know this listening to the Israeli media, who have joined forces with European and Palestinian spin doctors to foster anti-Israel propaganda. How many times did I hear the newscaster showing this shameful footage, call these kids: "Men of the Right." Men? I didn't see any men. I saw fifteen year-olds, confused and unhappy, and hyper.

Now why should that be? I mean, the fact that their government gave out guns to terrorists after signing worthless agreements with them couldn't be a factor, could it? Or the fact that they sat and had bombs thrown at them for four years, while their government was "negotiating." It couldn't be seeing their friends, neighbors, parents,teachers and Rabbis gunned down or blown up in cold blood by their Palestinian neighbors, could it? Or the fact that they are about to lose their homes and have their synagogues, schools and even cemeteries, bulldozed?

I mean, that's no excuse for sitting on the roads and blocking complacent Tel Aviv home-owners trying to get to their television sets and humus. No, they must be "dangerous criminals who will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law." Bad seeds, "men of the right," violent fanatics who deserve and who will receive, no doubt, long jail terms if Mr. Sharon and his forces get their hands on them.

I saw one of them throw a rock and injure a Palestinian, which was disgusting. This incident is now being denounced as a "lynch" (Lynch? You mean like the two Israeli reservists who were beaten to death by a Palestinian mob,who dipped their hands in the blood? That kind of lynch?)

Let's kill the kids, why don't we? After all, they are worse than terrorists aren't they, with their "lynch" and their desperate, annoying attempts to wake up their fellow citizens, keeping them in traffic jams in hot days. Or like the soldier who cried out: "This is wrong!" during an operation to drag the kids' bodily into waiting vans. He was given the maximum jail sentence. Not for refusing orders, mind you. For expressing his feelings. Let's string him up, too.

Disengagement: To detach oneself. Free oneself from an obligation or pledge. To withdraw. I guess that's how I feel about my government and the Israeli news media today. I'm disengaged. I think I speak for many.

Views expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect those of israelinsider.


 Talk Back! Respond to this view



Click on the blue headline to read a Talkback comment and respond to it. Click on the icon to send a private email to the talkback writer. The icon appears only if the writer has decided to be contacted. If no popup window appears, please make sure your popup blocker allows israelinsider.com.

 
  | about |   partners |   sponsor |   donate |   news |   subscribe |   contact |