Israel's daily newsmagazine
   Israel's daily newsmagazine
| home |   security |   politics |   diplomacy |   anti-semitism |   culture |   travel |   views | today's weblog  
 
Diplomacy > "Roadmap"

   



 
Sign up for free!

E-mail
 
         
       
         










Dr. Aaron Lerner is co-founder of IMRA, Independent Media Review and Analysis, an Israel-based news organization which provides an extensive digest of media, polls and significant interviews and events relating to the Israeli-Arab conflict.
imra@netvision.net.il
Previous views
Will Olmert's move against settlers quash the retreat?
Bush's support for Sharon was mostly rhetoric
Post-Sharon Elections: Program Trumps (lack of) Personality
Former Shin Bet Chief squanders his integrity
Bibi's Choice: Defining the Likud democratically or dishonestly
Palestinian conditional non-violence denies the basis of the deal
Framing elections as retreat referendum could defeat Sharon
Clear Choices for a Change
After the "Peretz Earthquake"
Does it honor Rabin to distort his message?
Operation of passage points: not a question of "if" but "how"
Bush proves soft on Palestinian security compliance
Compensation for administrative detention: a small step forward
Rice soft on Hamas and disarming Palestinian terrorists
What did the Likud Central Committee vote mean?
Difference between Sharon-Peres and Netanyahu or Landau is fundamental
Has Israeli deterrence become a farce?
The Landau Candidacy
What President Katzav Could Have Said

As terror groups end truce, Israel to rethink "roadmap" if Hamas wins
Views: Past time to drop "Palestine"
Sharon denies claim he'll cede 90% of Judea and Samaria, split Jerusalem
Views: The Rafah Agreement is against the law, common sense and prudent self-defense
Former President Clinton: Iraq invasion was a big mistake
Condi passed around laptop, passed on sleep, as Israel caved on crossings
Sharon says he won't meet Abbas until PA leader acts against terrorists
Views: "Painful Concessions"
Views: Changing Emphasis

 
Will giving terrorists day-jobs as cops fulfill the Roadmap?
By Dr. Aaron Lerner   January 26, 2006


If the Palestinian Authority (PA) gives all the armed terrorists day-jobs as cops would that constitute "breaking up the terror infrastructure"?

The PA leadership thinks so.

And Israel's Foreign Minister Livni, perhaps out of a desire to keep Israel's options open, declines to take a position.

This is a terrible mistake by all counts.

The Oslo experience has shown time and again that giving terrorists a badge and a salary doesn't prevent them from moonlighting as terrorists. If anything, the police training only makes them more dangerous, as demonstrated by the CIA trained policemen/terrorist sharpshooters.

Some have tried to draw a parallel between the recruitment of members of the various Jewish underground groups into the IDF at the founding of the State of Israel, but the comparison fails on all counts:

The members of the Jewish underground groups were drafted into the IDF to help protect the fledgling State from annihilation -- not take them off the streets.

The Palestinians have the great luxury of not needing to waste their resources on an army to battle their enemies: they did, after all, commit to resolve their disputes with Israel via peaceful means, and they can rely on Israel to defend their areas from foreign invasion.

The PA doesn't need a huge army. It needs an efficient, professional, police force. It doesn't need tens of thousands of assault-rifle-bearing forces. A few disciplined SWAT teams would suffice.

Want to give the terrorists jobs to they get off the streets?

Fine.

But not as cops.

Views expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect those of israelinsider.


 Talk Back! Respond to this view



Click on the blue headline to read a Talkback comment and respond to it. Click on the icon to send a private email to the talkback writer. The icon appears only if the writer has decided to be contacted. If no popup window appears, please make sure your popup blocker allows israelinsider.com.

 
  | about |   partners |   sponsor |   donate |   news |   subscribe |   contact |